Per his live service initiative. 2022, 23, 24, 25, 26 (still ongoing as some of those games are still in development hell). That's 6.5 billion dollars lost. And that 767 million? That's a write off/down. The only way that's a negative, is IF... they had tax exceptions directly tied to Bungie's initial evaluations. Sony recouped 767 million as result of that impairment loss. That's how write offs work. 😇👍💠 If you want to make Bungie the scapegoat for Jim Ryan's bad decisions, I think Sony would love nothing better. Not what Shuhei Yoshida said though, is saying... he puts it squarely on Jim's shoulders.